A surviving spouse can pursue permanent partial disability benefits that were rated but never paid during the injured worker's lifetime, at least where both sides' doctors gave the same rating. That is the result of Hasselt v. Lufthansa German Airlines, 6575 CRB-7-25-4, decided by Connecticut's Compensation Review Board on April 24, 2026.
The case turns on a phrase that comes up often in these disputes: whether there was a "meeting of the minds" on the disability rating before the worker died.
What happened
The worker injured his lumbar spine on July 6, 1994, and began receiving temporary total disability benefits that December. Two doctors later rated his back:
- June 1, 1995: the respondents' examiner assigned a 25% permanent partial disability of the lumbar spine.
- January 18, 1996: the treating physician assigned the same 25% rating.
Despite those ratings, the worker stayed on temporary total disability for nearly three decades, until his death on January 3, 2024. The permanent partial disability benefits were never paid. After he died, his surviving spouse asked for them.
The first ruling: no agreement, no benefits
The administrative law judge denied the claim. At the formal hearing the parties had filed a joint stipulation reciting both 25% ratings and had jointly submitted both doctors' reports. Even so, the judge found no award or finding of a disability rating as of the date of death, and no agreement between the parties that amounted to a meeting of the minds on the rating.
The judge relied heavily on Brennan v. Waterbury, 331 Conn. 672 (2019). In Brennan, the worker had received several different ratings, and his surviving spouse sought payment for an 80% rating of the heart. The Connecticut Supreme Court found no meeting of the minds on that record.
The Court left a door open, though. In a comment not essential to its ruling, it said an argument could be made that the parties had agreed on the lowest rating the worker received, which was 50%. It called that a question of first impression and left it for another day.
The Board reverses
The Compensation Review Board reversed and sent the case back. It pointed to three things:
- The ratings matched. The respondents' examiner and the treating physician each put the lower back at 25%. Unlike Brennan, there was no spread of competing numbers.
- Both doctors found maximum medical improvement. Each said the worker had reached that point on the date of the examination.
- The joint stipulation confirmed it. In the Board's view, the stipulation entered at trial further showed that both sides accepted the 25% rating.
The Board found this situation consistent with the scenario the Supreme Court described in Brennan. It said it could not discern the basis for the judge's conclusion that no agreement existed.
What is still undecided
The spouse has not yet been awarded a dollar figure. The respondents argued that they are owed a credit against the permanent partial disability benefits for all indemnity benefits paid after the worker reached maximum medical improvement, citing footnote nine of McCurdy v. State, 227 Conn. 261 (1993).
Because the judge had denied the claim outright, that question was never reached. The Board directed the judge to decide two things on remand: the credit, and the date of maximum medical improvement. With temporary total benefits paid for decades after the ratings, the answers could substantially affect what, if anything, is actually paid.
What this means in practice
- Matching ratings carry weight. When both sides' doctors agree on the rating and on maximum medical improvement, that can amount to a meeting of the minds, even without a formal award or signed agreement during the worker's lifetime.
- Stipulations matter. A joint stipulation reciting the ratings was treated as further evidence of mutual acceptance.
- Competing ratings are a different case. Brennan still stands where the record shows several different ratings and no sign the parties settled on one.
- The credit question is live. How much a prior stream of indemnity payments offsets a later permanency claim remains to be decided in this case.
This post is a general summary for informational purposes and is not legal advice. If you have questions about how this decision may affect a claim, please contact our office.














Comments
There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.
Leave a Comment